As Washington DC becomes the latest US city to impose a levy not only on plastic bags but on paper carrier bags as well, FIE has written to the Minister for the Environment warning him that Ireland will be left behind by ignoring the science which shows that paper bags have a greater adverse impact than plastic bags for a number of the environmental issues. Ireland intends to increase the levy from 22c to 44c this year but the 2008 Regulatory Impact Analysis that examined the levy had paper bags specifically excluded from its terms of reference.

Successful legislation in Portland, Seattle, Los Angeles, and San Francisco are part of a wave of more than 30 bag taxes have been proposed across American cities in the past year. The need for the extension of the levy is particularly acute in Ireland as the plastic carrier bag has been displacied by an almost equal number of damaging paper carrier bags. Reusable bags only, please - and a rebate to the retailer from the levy as these take longer to pack than plastic bags.

Read the Press Release | The letter to the Minister | The Scottish Study  |

The Sunday Times 'Think Tank' piece  |   Radio interview with Gareth O'Callahan on 4FM


Call for study as Ireland ‘left behind in carrier bag levies'

Washington DC has become the latest US city to impose a levy not only on plastic bags but on paper carrier bags as well. The US Capital city follows successful legislation in Portland, Seattle, Los Angeles, and San Francisco as more than 20 bag taxes have been proposed across American cities in the past year.

In a letter to the Minister, FIE points out that international studies that show that paper carrier bags should be included in any plastic bag levy as ‘paper bags have a greater adverse impact than a plastic bag for a number of the environmental issues'.

The group quotes a Scottish study, which shows the damaging effects of paper bags in their manufacture as well as in the waste stream. The studies are based on life cycle analysis [LCA] which considers the impact throughout the lifetime of an object.

Manufacturing paper bags increases water consumption, atmospheric acidification (which can have effects on human health, sensitive ecosystems, forest decline and acidification of lakes) and eutrophication of water bodies (which can lead to growth of algae and depletion of oxygen).

The group says that ‘need for the extension of the level is particularly acute as the successful plastic carrier bag levy is increasing the use of these damaging paper carrier bags. A paper bag weighs roughly six times more than plastic, is about four times more expensive and takes up to ten times more storage space. A higher incidence of double bagging of paper bags for strength as well as heavier paper bags is another result of the levy.

A spokesman noted that studies show that ‘a reusable bag used more than four times is the best environmental option - and it is one that does not increase the taxation burden on the consumer.'

Some of the new US levies incorporate encouragement for retailers that provide incentives for reusable bags and allow retailers to keep a small percentage themselves.

In Ireland, the funds are used for valuable environmental initiatives such as the recent surface cleanup of historic contamination on Haulbowline Island in Cork Harbour.

The Minister should re-examine the current levy to ensure that Ireland is making the best use of the environmental and economic opportunities in the light of what is happening elsewhere in the world.

 

 

  • No comments found
Add comment